Great Victory for Military Voting Rights
By Captain Samuel F. Wright, JAGC, USN (Ret.)
7.0—Military Voting Rights
Doe v. Walker, Case No. RWT-10cv2646 (District of Maryland Oct. 29, 2010).
“It is axiomatic that a state may not erect obstacles which deprive a group of citizens of the fundamental right to vote absent sufficient justification. Louisiana v. United States, 380 U.S. 145 (1965). This case requires the Court to determine whether preliminary injunctive relief should be granted to the Plaintiffs on their claim that the manner in which Maryland is conducting absentee voting for state offices in the November 2, 2010 election deprives absent uniformed services voters and overseas voters of their fundamental right to vote. As explained below, the Court concludes that it does, and, by separate order, a preliminary injunction will be entered.”
This is the first paragraph of the scholarly and eloquent decision of Judge Roger W. Titus of the United States District Court for the District of Maryland. This is the case that I discussed in Law Review 1064 (October 2010). I invite the reader’s attention to www.roa.org/law_review. You will find more than 750 articles about the Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act (UOCAVA), the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA), the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA), and other laws that are particularly pertinent to those who serve our nation in uniform. You will also find a detailed Subject Index and a search function, to facilitate finding articles about very specific topics.
The Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act (UOCAVA), a federal statute enacted in 1986 and codified in title 42 of the United States Code, gives “absent uniformed services voters” and “overseas voters” the right to vote by absentee ballot in primary, general, special, and runoff elections for federal office (President, U.S. Senator, and U.S. Representative). “Absent uniformed services voters” are members of the U.S. uniformed services (Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, Coast Guard, Public Health Service commissioned corps, and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration commissioned corps) in active service who are absent, because of their service, from their places of domicile, either within or outside the United States. Voting age family members of uniformed services members also qualify as “absent uniformed services voters” when they are absent from their places of domicile because they are accompanying service members serving within or outside the United States. “Overseas voters” are U.S. citizens of voting age who are outside the United States temporarily or permanently.
UOCAVA is silent as to the eligibility of military and overseas citizens to vote for non-federal offices, like the Maryland Senate or House of Delegates, but virtually all military personnel and family members and some overseas civilians are eligible under state law to vote for all offices. A person who is away from his or her place of domicile for temporary purposes (even for many years) does not lose the domicile.
“For purposes of voting for any Federal office … or a State or local office, a person who is absent from a State in compliance with military or naval orders shall not solely by reason of that absence—(1) be deemed to have lost a residence or domicile in that State, without regard to whether or not the person intends to return to that State; (2) be deemed to have acquired a residence or domicile in any other State; or (3) be deemed to have become a resident in or a resident of any other State.” 50 U.S.C. App. 595 (emphasis supplied). This provision is part of the SCRA.
In October 2009, Congress enacted the Military and Overseas Voter Empowerment Act (MOVE Act), as part of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2010. The MOVE Act made several important and helpful amendments to UOCAVA. As amended by the MOVE Act, UOCAVA now explicitly requires each state to mail absentee ballots at least 45 days before Election Day to UOCAVA voters, military and civilian. If a state is unable to meet the 45-day requirement because of an undue hardship caused by something like a late primary, the state can apply to the Secretary of Defense (SECDEF) for a one-time waiver of the 45-day rule. To obtain the waiver, the state must show both an undue hardship and a satisfactory alternative arrangement (satisfactory to SECDEF) that gives UOCAVA voters sufficient time to receive, mark, and return their absentee ballots, despite the state having missed the 45-day deadline.
The Maryland State Board of Elections (MSBE) applied to SECDEF for a waiver on July 28, 2010, contending that the primary scheduled for September 14, 2010 (just 49 days before the general election) made it impossible for the state to meet the 45-day rule, because it takes more than four days to certify the primary winners and print and mail general election ballots. On August 25, the MSBE wrote to SECDEF again and withdrew the July 28 waiver request. The MSBE promised to mail absentee ballots for federal offices only by Saturday, September 18, and the MSBE met that deadline. The ballots for all offices were not mailed until well into October.
The Military Voter Protection Project (MVPP) filed this lawsuit in the United States District Court for the District of Maryland, on behalf of John Doe, the pseudonym for a Maryland Army National Guard officer serving on active duty in Iraq. The MVPP contended that the constitutional right to vote of John Doe and others similarly situated was violated by Maryland’s untimely mailing of absentee ballots. Judge Titus agreed and granted the requested relief.
Judge Titus ordered Maryland to extend by ten days (beyond the ten days already provided by state law) the deadline for the receipt of absentee ballots mailed in from outside the United States, including APO and FPO addresses. On Tuesday, November 23 (three weeks after Election Day), the county boards of elections counted overseas ballots received between November 3 (the day after Election Day) and November 22 (20 days after Election Day). These ballots were counted for all offices.
Maryland did not appeal. We will keep the readers informed of developments on this important issue.
 Eric Eversole, a Commander in the Navy Reserve Judge Advocate General’s Corps and a member of ROA, is the Executive Director of the MVPP.